Apr 29

A Snapshot of the Past-Five Generations of My Family

Front: William Reid, Gertrude (Brewster) Miller, Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington. Back: Pearl (Reid) Brewster, Elvira (Headington) Reid. c1898

This five generation photo is one of my favorites. William Reid, featured in my latest Tombstone Tuesday blog, is the man seated in the photo and is my second great grandfather. The little girl in the photo is my grandmother, Gertrude Miller, nee Brewster. Her mother, Pearl Brewster, nee Reid, is standing on the left. William was Pearl’s father. William’s mother, Elvira Reid, nee Headington, is standing on the right. Elvira’s mother, Mary Ann Headington, nee Cotterell, is seated on the right.

This photo and accompanying story was reprinted on 18 April 1957 in The Graphic, a newspaper published in Portland, Indiana. The original story was published 21 Feb 1903. The article states that the photo was taken in 1903, but my grandmother was born in 1896 and she doesn’t look as though she was 6 or 7 years old in the photo. I would guess the photo was taken about 1898. The article:

PIONEERS IN PORTLAND—Mrs. Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington, of West Main Street, here, boasts of living representatives of five generations, and she, the head of the list, carried her 87 years with an easy grace that marks her as an altogether unusual type. She is the widow of William Headington, a brother of Judge JW Headington and Col. Nimrod Headington, citizens prominent in all the best enterprises of Portland since first they cast in their lot with the struggling Hoosier hamlet on the Salamonie.

William and Mary A C Headington came west fifty-two years ago, leaving the old home in Baltimore, Maryland, on their wedding morn and making the long journey overland in an old-time “prairie schooner,” capacious and comfortable. Their wedding trip occupied fourteen days.

When they first arrived in Portland, the place was but a small village, the log houses nestling down among the forest trees. Mrs. Headington is remarkably bright, active and light of foot, and takes great pride in attending to her household duties. The reason for this young-old lady’s vigorous intellect, sunny, helpful character and strong body may be found in the fact that she has always faced life with cheerful heart, absorbing its sweetness and light and touching lightly its bitterness and shadows.

Her reminiscences of the early years in Portland are exceedingly interesting and inspiring. She has helped into life, and prepared for burial more people than did any other person who has ever lived in Portland. A call came for her one night in the long ago when the waters were up from Meridian Street to Pleasant Street. Her husband was away from home at the time, but she turned the key in the door, leaving her four little ones asleep, mounted her trusty horse and drawing her feet into the saddle went through the waters to the house of death, prepared the body for the coffin and was back at home before daylight.

Thirty-eight years ago Mrs. Headington saw a snow storm on the 4th of July which bowed the wheat crop to the ground. She gathered her first mess of green peas of that season from under the snow. Two of her daughters went to a Sunday School picnic that day dressed in white, wearing blanket shawls. Their escorts wore white duck pans and black coats.

January, 1903, Mrs. Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington has seventeen living grandchildren, three great-grandchildren, ten great-great-grandchildren, and ten great-great-great grandchildren. Few mothers live to see ten children of the fifth generation.

This article was written by a special Star correspondent, Charlotte Archer Raney.

Caption under photo, 1957: Edith L. Stroube, 615 West High Street, Portland, submits this “Old Album” shot of a five generation picture of the Headington family, starting with Edith Stroube’s great grandmother, Mrs. Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington, seated right. Identifying the generations, seated left to right, are William Reid (father), Gertie (Brewster) Miller (niece), and Mrs. Headington. Standing left to right are Mrs. Pearl (Reid) Brewster (sister), and Mrs. Elvira (Headington) Reid (grandmother). This picture was taken in January 1903 and, appeared with an interesting story of the Headington family in “struggling Hoosier hamlet on the Salamonie.” (source: The Graphic, Portland, Indiana, 18 April 1957)

I have used this photo and the accompanying article as proof of descent for several lineage applications, including a DAR application. It is interesting to note that Elvira, William, Pearl, and Gertrude were the first born in each of their families. The article states that William and Mary Ann Headington came west 52 years ago, which would be 1851. I believe they meant that the couple came to Portland or Jay County in 1851. Their daughter Elvira was born in Knox County, Ohio, about 1838, according to her obituary. William and Mary Ann were living in Delaware County, Ohio, in 1840 and in Franklin County, Ohio, in 1850, according to census enumerations.

Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington passed on 19 June 1903, just a few months after the article was written. Here are the vital dates of those in the photo: Mary Ann (Cotterell) Headington (1816-1903); Elvira (Headington) Reid (1838-1911); William Reid (1855-1905); Pearl (Reid) Brewster (1880-1962); Gertrude (Brewster) Miller (1896-1973).

Apr 26

Tombstone Tuesday–William W. & Emily E. (Bryan) Reid

William W. Reid & Emily E. nee Bryan, Green Park Cemetery, Jay County, Indiana

This is the tombstone of William W. and Emily E. (Bryan) Reid, located in Green Park Cemetery, Portland, Jay County, Indiana. William and Emily were my second great grandparents. The marker is inscribed:

REID
William W. Reid
1855-1906
Emily E. His Wife
1856-1940

William (2 February 1855-2 February 1905) was the son of Daniel and Elvira Reid, nee Headington. Emily E. Bryan (8 May 1856-24 June 1940) was the daughter of John and Hannah Bryan, nee Huey. William married Emily E. Bryan on 30 June 1878 in Jay County, Indiana. (Vol. D:442)   Emily remarried to Abraham C. Bisel on 20 December 1913 in Jay County. (Vol. 9:99) William and Emily had seven daughters: Pearl, Laura, Minnie, Zorpha, Edith, Hannah, and Gladys. I descend from Pearl.

Obituary:
WILLIAM REID DEAD–Wm. Reid died at half past six o’clock Thursday evening at his late home in Portland, from a lingering illness of creeping paralysis. The deceased leaves a wife and six children. For many years Mr. Reid and his family were residents of near New Corydon, and moved to their home on Water Street, about a year ago.  He was born February 2, 1855, and at the time of his death was fifty years of age. Eight brothers and sisters survive, whose names are C.T. Reid, of South Bend, Albert, Roland and A.J. Reid of this city, Harry Reid and Mrs. Minnie Borden of Hartford City, James Reid, of Kansas, and Lowell Reid, of Muncie.  The funeral service took place Saturday afternoon at two o’clock at the Evangelical church, conducted by the Rev. W.S. Tracq. Interment in Green Park Cemetery. (source: The Geneva Herald, 16 Feb 1905)

Obituary:
EMILY E. BISEL DIES MONDAY-Flu and Complications Fatal to West Water Street Resident-Emily E. Bisel, 84, resident of West Water Street, died Monday morning at 5 o’clock at the Jay County Hospital following an eleven week’s illness of flu and complications. She had been a lifelong resident of Jay County. Mrs. Bisel was born May 8, 1856, in Jay County, daughter of John and Hannah (Huey) Bryan. Her first marriage was June 29, 1878 (sic), to William W. Reid, who died February 9, 1903 (sic). She was later married Abram C. Bisel, now deceased.  Surviving are five daughters, Mrs. Pearl Brewster of New Corydon, Mrs. Minnie Brockway of Portland, Mrs. Zorpha Lawrence of Fort Wayne, Mrs. Edith VanSkyock and Mrs. Gladys Lare of Portland; 30 grandchildren; 42 great grandchildren and one sister, Mrs. Ernest Schmidt of northeast of Portland. Two daughters are deceased. The body was removed to the Baird funeral home where friends may call.  Funeral arrangements have not been completed. (source: clipping from unknown newspaper, dated June 1940, obtained from Hazel Brewster in 1999)

As so often happens, there are a couple discrepancies among the records. William and Emily’s marriage return shows they were married on 30 June, not 29 June, as stated in Emily’s obituary. The year of William’s death is incorrect in Emily’s obituary. He died in 1905, not 1903. William’s death record from the Jay County Health Department and Emily’s obituary both state that William died on 9 February, but the JL Baird Funeral Home Records show that he was buried on 4 February. I checked a 1905 calendar and both February 2nd and 9th were on a Thursday, which agrees with William’s obituary. His obituary states only that he died on Thursday. Is the funeral home record wrong or is the Health Department record wrong?  We have to remember that there can be errors in any record. Therefore we have to carefully study all of the information, take into consideration the events that were occurring at that time, and consider who may have provided the information in order to determine what is most likely correct.

William W. Reid (1855-1905), photo c1898

Emily E. Reid, nee Bryan (1856-1940)

Apr 22

I’m My Own Grandpa

Unknown tintype; a Schinnerer?

“I’m My Own Grandpa” is the title of an old song that my parents used to have on a 78 Rpm record. The song was written by Dwight Latham and Moe Jaffe back in the 1940s.  It was from the same era as another silly song, “Does Your Chewing Gum Lose Its Flavor on the Bedpost Overnight?” They don’t write songs like that anymore and they don’t make 78 Rpm records anymore either. Ray Stevens rerecorded the grandpa song a few years back and some of you may be familiar with it.

“I’m My Own Grandpa” tells the tale of tangled relationships in a family and how a man ended up being related to himself. It seems this fellow married a woman that had a grown daughter from a previous marriage. That fellow’s father married the daughter, making his father his son-in-law. Sort of. I guess to be genealogically accurate they should have used the term “step” throughout the song, as in step-daughter. But that would have thrown off the meter of the song.

My Tombstone Tuesday blog, featuring Barbara Anna Schumm Buechner, nee Pflueger, brought this song to mind, although our family genealogy is not quite as intriguing as the one in the song. In my family no one ended up being their own grandpa, but there are a couple minor twists and turns.

I knew that my Grandpa and Grandma Schumm were related by blood before they married. Louis and Barbara Schumm, nee Pflueger, were the common ancestors of both Grandpa and Grandma. Grandpa descended from their son Louis and Grandma descended from their daughter Elizabeth, who married Friedrich Schinnerer.

People did not go very far to find a mate in the 19th century. They often married someone within three miles of where they lived. The Schumms and Scaers lived just down the road from each other.

My grandparents were first cousins once removed. Another way to look at it would be to marry the son or daughter of your first cousin. Isaac and Rebeckah, of Biblical fame, were also first cousins once removed. Several notable people married their first cousin, including Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin, and Queen Victoria. First cousin marriages are fairly common throughout the world, making up about 10% of all marriages. But remember, my grandparents were first cousins once removed. There is an extra little buffer in there. Theoretically, that would be half as risky as marrying your first cousin, if you are concerned about passing on a genetic disease.

I was surprised a few years ago when one of my relatives, Milton Schumm and his wife Betty, came to the funeral home after the death of Joe’s grandmother, Goldie Helen Roesner, nee Lee. As we talked with them we learned that not only had they been acquaintances of the Roesners, but one of them was related to Joe! Immediately I wondered if Joe and I were somehow related. As soon as I got home I delved into my genealogy information to see just what their relationship was to us.

I discovered that Milton Schumm was my 2nd cousin once and twice removed. I’m related to Milton twice because of that Louis and Barbara Schumm thing again. Louis and Barbara are the common ancestors of Milton and me.

It turns out that Joe is related to Milton’s wife, Betty, nee Ross. Joe and Betty are 1st cousins once removed. Their common ancestors are Dietrich and Christine Roesner, nee Schoor. Dietrich and Christine Roesner had 8 children. Among them were Edward Roesner, Joe’s grandfather and husband of Goldie Helen Lee, and Elizabeth Louise Roesner, who married Leo Ross. Louise and Leo had 4 children and one of them was Betty Ross, who married Milton Schumm. It turns out that Betty is the niece of Edward and Helen Roesner.

Joe and I are not related by blood. As for our son Jeff, he is of course related to both Milton and Betty. He is a 2nd cousin twice and three times removed to Milton and a 1st cousin twice removed to Betty. I could go on and give Jeff’s relationship to Milton and Betty’s children, but this first, second cousin, once, twice removed  thing is making my head hurt. Thanks to Roots Magic and its Relationship Calculator, which makes figuring out these family relationships very easy.

Apr 19

Tombstone Tuesday–Barbara Anna (Pflueger) Schumm Buechner

Barbara Anna Schumm Buechner, nee Pflueger (1822-1908), Zion Lutheran Cemetery, Schumm, Ohio

This is the tombstone of Barbara Anna Buechner, nee Pflueger, located in row 4 of Zion Lutheran Cemetery, Schumm, Van Wert County, Ohio.The marker is inscribed:

Barbara A.
28 Dec. 1822
13 Nov. 1908
Alter
85 J, 10 M, 15 T
BUECHNER

Barbara Anna was the seventh of twelve children born to Johann Christian and Anna Barbara (Seckel) Pflueger, born 28 December 1822 in Schrozberg, Oberamt Gerebronn, Wuerttemberg. She immigrated with her family in about 1832 and they first settled Holmes County, Ohio.

Barbara married Johann Ludwig Schumm in Holmes County, Ohio, on 1 November 1840 by Daniel Cranz. (Vol. 2:109) I descend from their son Louis J. and his wife Sarah (Breuninger) and from their daughter Elizabeth, who married Friedrich Schinnerer. Barbara is my second and third great-grandmother.

Barbara’s first husband Ludwig Schumm died in 1855 and she then married John Adam Buechner on 17 September 1861 in Van Wert County, Ohio. (Vol. 2:274)

Obituary:
LADY PASSES AWAY–A RESIDENT OF THE TOWNSHIP 68 YEARS
In the death of Mrs. Anna Barbara Buechner, which occurred at Schumm Friday, a pioneer resident has been called to her last home. Mrs. Buechner having been a resident of this township for sixty-eight years. She had been failing in health for some time, due to the infirmities of old age.

Anna Barbara Buechner, nee Flager [sic], was born Dec. 28, 1822 in Schroedsberg (sic), Oberamt Gerebronn, Wuerttemberg, in Germany, coming to this country in 1831 when her parents located in Holmes County, Ohio, where she resided until the year of 1840, when she was united in marriage to Martin [sic] Ludwig Schumm, and moved to what is now the J.C. Schumm property at Schumm.

To this union nine children were born, they being Elizabeth, now Mrs. Frederick Schinnerer; Mary, who was united in marriage to Martin Schinnerer, but now deceased; Henry; Jacob, now deceased; Rosina, now the second wife of Martin Schinnerer, of Los Angeles, Calif.; J.C. and Louis J.; Hannah, now Mrs. C.F. Germann and George, deceased. In 1855 Mr. Schumm passed to the great beyond and Mrs. Schumm remained a widow until the year of 1861, when she was united in marriage to John Adam Buechner, to which union two children were born, they being Marguerite, now the wife of F.G. Kreiselmeyer of Ft. Wayne, and W.A. Buechner.  Mr. Buechner answered the last call March 11, 1885, since which time she has remained a widow.  All the children living were present at the funeral services with the exception of Mrs. Martin Schinnerer of Los Angeles, Calif. 

Mrs. Buechner leaves to mourn their loss, four sons, four daughters, three son-in-laws (sic), three daughter-in-laws (sic), two step-sons, one sister, Mrs. Jacob Bienz, fifty-five grandchildren and sixty-four great grand children. The funeral services were held at the Zion Lutheran Church at Schumm, Monday, November 16, conducted by the pastor, Rev. H. Holle, the interment being made in the church cemetery.  Four of the great-grandsons acted as pall-bearers, carrying the remains of Mrs. Buechner to her last resting place. (The Willshire Herald, 19 Nov 1908, p. 1)

Barbara and Ludwig Schumm had the following children:

Elizabeth (1841-1917) married Friedrich Schinnerer
Maria “Mary” (1842-1870) married Martin Schinnerer
Henry (1844-1922) married Anna Schinnerer; Anna Magdalena “Lena” Geisler
Johann Jacob (1846-1854)
“Rosina” Maria (1848-1909) married Martin Schinnerer
John C. (1849-1926)  married Wilhelmina “Minnie” Breuninger
George (1850-1852)
Ludwig John (1851-1938) married Sarah Breuninger
Hannah (1853-1926) married Charles Germann
George Friedrick (1855-1857)

Barbara and John Adam Buechner had the following children:

Marguerite  (1864-?) married F.G. Kreiselmeyer
William A. (1865-1955) Katherine Magdalena Schumm

 

Apr 15

Our Century Families of Ohio

Karen, Joe, Jeff, Sunda Peters, OGS President at 2011 Century Families Inductions

A couple of weeks ago we were in Columbus for the 50th Annual Ohio Genealogical Society Conference. Thursday evening Joe, Jeff and I attended the Century Families of Ohio banquet and afterward the three of us were inducted into the new lineage society. Century Families of Ohio (CFO) is the newest OGS lineage society and we are now charter members. You are eligible to join if you are an OGS member and can prove your direct descent from an ancestor that resided in Ohio between 1861 and 100 years ago, which was 1910 last year. Last year I submitted applications for all three of us and all of our ancestors were approved!

Ninety-three CFO applications were approved and the majority of those applicants were present at the induction ceremony. It was quite a crowd. Those 93 applicants proved 541 ancestors. Sixty-three ancestors were from Coshocton County, the most ancestors from one particular Ohio county. Twenty-five ancestors were from Mercer County and twenty-two were from Van Wert County. Margaret Cheney, CFO chair, presided at the induction ceremony.

I was actually able to claim more ancestors than I first thought I would have. Most of my grandparents are now in the CFO roster. Below is a list of our CFO ancestors. Following their name is the earliest date they were in Ohio, the county they were proved in and the information I used to prove they were in Ohio between 1861-1910:

Karen (8 ancestors proved):
Carl Friedrich Miller (1896/Mercer/birth)
Jacob Miller (1874/Mercer/naturalization)
Christina Rueck (1882/Van Wert/marriage to Jacob Miller)
Cornelius Ludwig Schumm (1896/Van Wert/birth)
Sarah Breuninger (1883/Van Wert/marriage to Louis Schumm)
Elizabeth Schinnerer (1870/Mercer/birth)
John Scaer (1864/Tuscarawas/birth)
Hilda Magdalena Scaer (1910/Van Wert/1910 census)

Joe (13 ancestors proved):
Vermont Henry Bennett (1886/Mercer/birth)
Lura V Monroe (1890/Mercer/birth)
Sarah Elizabeth Cain (1878/Mercer/marriage to James Francis Monroe)
David B Cain (1880/Mercer/1880 census)
Narcissa Manning (1880/Mercer/1880 census)
Edward Roesner (1893/Van Wert/birth)
Goldie Helen Lee (1905/Paulding/birth)
Dietrick Roesner (1880/Paulding/1880 census)
Christine Schoor (1862/Putnam/birth)
Hiram Lee (1890/Paulding/marriage to Arretha Green)
Arretha Green (1890/Paulding/marriage to Hiram Lee)
Stephen Lee (1900/Paulding/1900 census)
Phebe Howard (1900/Paulding/1900 census)

Jeff, 21 ancestors proved. He was of course credited with all of the above ancestors. Jeff had the most ancestors proved of all those inducted this year! I am CFO #16, Joe is #17, and Jeff is #18. We each received a nice medallion and a certificate.

I would have been able to prove Jacob and Regina (Gross) Rueck if I had found their Van Wert County land deed last year. They were in Van Wert in 1881.I plan to submit the necessary documents to prove them this year. If approved, they will be in next year’s roster.

If you notice, all the women are listed by their maiden name. A woman’s maiden name must be proved to be accepted into a lineage society. To prove Regina Rueck, nee Gross, I will use a copy of daughter Christina’s birth/baptism record from the Evangelical Church in Honhardt, Wuerttemberg. Translations are accepted for lineage applications, but the translation must be done by someone other than the applicant. Although I can read the record myself, I will have someone translate and transcribe the document for the application.

I am a member of all four OGS lineage societies: First Families of Ohio/FFO (ancestor resided in Ohio before 1821); Settlers and Builders of Ohio/SBO (ancestor resided in Ohio between 1821-1861), Society of Civil War Families of Ohio/SCWFO (ancestor served in the Civil War with an Ohio unit or resided in Ohio at one time); and Century Families of Ohio/CFO (1861-100 years from current year).

Except for SCWFO, an ancestor can only be in one OGS lineage society. Since SCWFO is a Civil War society the residency date doesn’t matter, just that the ancestor served in the Civil War and was in an Ohio unit or lived in Ohio. The other three societies are based on lineage and Ohio residency during a certain time period. The ancestor should be proved at the earliest date possible. Therefore, even though some of my other ancestors were in Ohio between 1821-1910, they were proved for SBO and were not eligible for CFO. A little confusing, but it makes sense if you think about it.

Although applying to a lineage society is a lot of work, it is a wonderful way to honor your ancestors and it is a very good way to have your research evaluated and critiqued by another person. As you complete the application you will quickly see what documents you still need to prove vital dates, relationships or residency. I plan to apply to more lineage societies in the future. I do enjoy lineage societies!

Century Families of Ohio medallion