Beating the Heat

This has been a rather uncomfortable summer, weather-wise, although the past couple days have been more bearable and we received some much-needed rain. The heat is bad enough, but is worse when combined with high humidity.

It’s not the heat, it’s the humidity.

Heat and humidity seem to go together here in Ohio in the summertime, making it very uncomfortable to be outdoors.  

I’m glad it’s finally hot enough to complain about how hot it is.

Air-conditioning is a wonderful way to stay comfortable in the summer, but I remember the time before air-conditioning was widely used.

When I grew up we did not have air-conditioning. Not at home, not at school, not at church, not in our vehicles. We still don’t have air-conditioning at church, but a ceiling fan moves the air pretty well.

How did we tolerate the heat and humidity in those days before air-conditioning?

How did our ancestors tolerate the heat?

They had many clever tricks.

Trees were strategically placed around their homes to block the sunshine. Homes were equipped with awnings and external shutters to block the sun. My Schumm grandparents had external shutters on their home.

Homes were built with airflow in mind, windows and doors situated to allow breezes to flow through the house. Homes had high ceilings and there were often transoms above the doors for even more airflow.

Grandma Schumm kept their house cool by keeping it closed up and keeping the window shades pulled down. That worked very well, but as a result her house was also rather dark inside. The pulled shades gave the house an eerie amber tint.

Many homes back then had a summer kitchen, a separate building where they cooked meals and canned their produce, keeping the heat away from the main house. Grandma Schumm had a summer kitchen, Grandma Miller did not.

If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

People worked smart, if they could. They did most of their outdoor work in the a.m., when it was cooler. This principle usually did not pertain to baling hay and farming in general. It seems they pick the hottest day to bale hay. 

If people were able to get their work done before noon, they would sit on the porch in the afternoon, probably with a glass of cold water or lemonade. Some families even ate their evening meal on the porch.

It’s a sure sign of summer if the chair gets up when you do.

Grandpa Miller spent hot summer afternoons sitting under a shade tree or reclining in his hammock which was strung between two weeping willow trees.

People used hand fans to move the air close to them. Fans were made of silk or paper and some paper fans later had advertising on them. We still have a few paper stick hand fans at church, complements of local funeral homes.

Fan from Wendel Motor Sales, Chatt, Ohio

Fan from Wendel Motor Sales, Chatt, Ohio

Eventually floor and ceiling fans were run by electricity. One of the first ceiling fans, in the late 1880s, had fan blades connected to a sewing machine motor. The Millers had a fan shaped like a round metal ottoman that you could sit on or put your feet on. I was always careful to keep my fingers away from the blades of that fan. 

Vintage ottoman fan

Placing a block of ice in front of a fan was another cooling technique.

People dressed for the weather and wore clothing made from natural fibers in light colors. Men wore straw hats, while women wore bonnets and used parasols to shade them from the sun. Grandma Miller always wore a bonnet with a wide brim, but I don’t ever remember seeing Grandma Schumm wear a bonnet.

As a last resort, some people went away to the mountains or to the beach to beat the heat. Swimming is always cooling.

I guess the bottom line is that years ago people accepted the heat and did their best to deal with it, using means that were available to them during their time period.

Fan from Fisher Hardware, Chatt, Ohio

Fan from Fisher Hardware, Chatt, Ohio

Thirty years ago, in July 1995, Chicago had a deadly heat wave. There were 739 heat-related deaths in the city. And we were there on vacation, to visit the museums and parts of the city. It was very hot when we toured the German U-505 submarine at the Museum of Science and Industry. At that time the submarine was outside the museum and it was not air-conditioned. The guide told us that the 100 degree plus temperature inside the submarine was about the same temperature the vessel would have been when it was under the water. That would have been very uncomfortable.

I am just glad someone created air-conditioning.

Captain James Riley Chapter, NSDAR, Celina, Ohio

Mercer County once had a Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR) chapter, the Captain James Riley Chapter, in Celina. The Chapter’s charter was issued on 13 April 1935 with 13 Charter members: Florence (Hardman) Christian, Mary Bess (Christian) Kreimendahl, Helen (Kennedy) Riley, Edith (Heighton) Clark, Mary (Swen) Heighton, Flora (Andrews) Hoel, Gladys (Hoel) Kreimendahl, Florence (Priest) Shadaker, Catharine (Blackburn) Sharp, Grace (Riley) Snyder, Zenaide (Allen) Sterline, Ida (Zeller) Stubbs, and Ollene (Green) Straley.

This was the Captain James Riley Chapter DAR yearbook for the 1950-51 term.

Captain James Riley Chapter DAR, Celina, Ohio, 1950-1951

The yearbook includes the members’ names, their maiden names, the names or initials of their husbands, the names of the Revolutionary War soldiers from whom they descended and proved for the DAR, their National DAR number and their ancestor’s number, and some other Chapter details.

Captain James Riley Chapter DAR, Celina, Ohio, 1950-1951

By 1950 the Captain James Riley Chapter had grown to include 35 members. Their officers were Gladys Kreimendahl/Regent, Belva Stubbs/Vice-regent, Alice Hartzell/Recording Secretary, Doris Barber/Corresponding Secretary, Golde Shiverdecker/Treasurer, Nellie Dick/Registrar, Frances Rafferty/Historian, and Vida Dye/Chaplain.

Captain James Riley Chapter DAR, Celina, Ohio, 1950-1951

Below is a list of the 1950-51 Chapter members. I added the birth and death years and included the husbands’ full name if only initials were given. The ancestor’s name is the last name. I did not include the National Numbers.

Helen Elizabeth (Hainline) Andrews (1912-2003) (Mrs. Elmer G); ancestor Henry Cowen/Cowing
Doris Barber (1919-2012) (unmarried) David Hamilton
Ruth Joan (Hoel) Brandts (1912-2003) (Mrs. Theodore); William Murlin/Moreland
Edith Frances (Heighton) Clark (1892-1981) (Mrs. Cyril Leon); Christopher Brown
Nellie (Lutz) Dick (1888-1955) (Mrs. Walter Hubert Sr); Jacob Blosser
Vida (Constable) Dye (1886-1976) (Mrs. Wilbur Wilson); Elias Dugan
Mildred Caroline (Hamilton) Fischer (1905-1996) (Mrs. Joseph “Joe” Nicholas); Asa Hall
Helen (King) Freeman (1907-2000) (Mrs. Russell W); Jesse Rose
Frieda Leslie (Alexander) Fricke (1900-1972) (Mrs. Alexander R); Aaron Evans
Iola Pearl (Cowen) Hainline (1887-1958) (Mrs. Charles William); Henry Cowen/Cowing
Thelma B (Parrott) Hale (1910-1982) (Mrs. J Homer); William Murlin/Moreland
Ada (Hall) Hamilton (1880-1959) (Mrs. Lee Ivan); Asa Hall
Alice (Fast) Hartzell (1901-1974) (Mrs. Alpha R); John Jacob Fast
Janice (Perrott) Heisser (1913-1979) (Mrs. Robert); William Murlin/Moreland
Flore Belle (Andrews) Hoel (1864-1952) (Mrs. Remington David); Samuel Andrews
Orpha Iona (Werts) Jenkins (1880-?) (Mrs. Grover Cleveland); William Murlin/Moreland
Gladys (Hoel) Kreimendahl (1901-1999) (Mrs. Ernest P); Samuel Andrews
Zua (Murlin) Maurer (1888-1957) (Mrs. Fred W); William Murlin/Moreland
Ida Dudley (Craw) Miller (1917-1998) (Mrs. Cletus); Nehemiah Davis
Mildred M (Hoel) Pulskamp (1907-1976) (Mrs. Andreas S); William Murlin/Moreland
Frances (Foster) Rafferty (1903-2002) (Mrs. Bruce Lee); William Cloyd
Jean (Murlin) Rawers (1912-2002) (Mrs. Arlington Joseph); David Hamilton
Winifred (Johnson) Reiser (1899-1994) (Mrs. Carlton); William McCutcheon
Helen M (Kennedy) Riley (1907-1967) (Mrs. Roscoe D); William Neeley
Catharine (Blackburn) Sharp (1907-1996) (Mrs. Richard C); Isaac Manning Jr
Golde “Golda” Cathrine Shiverdecker (1889-1981) (unmarried); George Ward
Helen Margaret (Dick) Stallter, (1913-1967) (Mrs. Carl Eugene); Jacob Blosser
Ollene Doris (Green) Straley (1904-1983) (Mrs. Simon S); William Roebuck
Belva (Dine) Stubbs (1896-1983) (Mrs. Carroll Andrew); William Roebuck
Ida Zena (Zeller) Stubbs (1863-1952) (Mrs. Dr. William Cooper); John Kumler
Glee R Swigart (1930-2012) (m. Dr. John Keith Paul in 1951); George Ward
Mary Alice (Thomas) [Miller] (?) surname was Miller per DAR; John Jacob Fast
Virginia (Honnold) Wiley (1913-1981) (Mrs. Leson A “Al”); George Seeger
Mary Leah (Clanin) Wolfe (1923-2003) (Mrs. Harry T); Phillip Dotterer
Charlotte (Putman) Wright (1899-1984) (Mrs. Perry Sylvester); William Roebuck

A couple of these women were born during the Civil War!

By 1950 five members of the Chapter had passed away: Mary (Swan) Heighton, Emma (Hitchens) Green, Grace (Riley) Snyder, Alice (hill), Mowery, and Daisy (Brookhart) Hoel.

Below are the names of the Revolutionary War ancestors proved by the members of the Captain James Riley Chapter DAR in Celina and the names of the members who proved them. They had to prove that they descended from the colonial individual and prove their ancestor’s service or aid in the American Revolution.  

All of these Revolutionary War soldiers are still listed in the DAR and could be proved by a descendant. However, William Roebuck and Jacob Kumler are currently red-flagged by the DAR. Roebuck has a problem with his war service, “DAR Future applicants must prove correct service” and Kumler has a lineage problem on at least one proven application. I included patriot information from the DAR website.   

Samuel Andrews (1741-1808), b. & d. Hartford Co Connecticut; Pvt/CT
>>Flora (Andrews) Hoel
>>Gladys (Hoel) Kreimendahl

Jacob Blosser (1758-1842), b. York PA, d. Columbiana Co OH; Pvt/PA
>>Nallie (Lutz) Dick
>>Helen (Dick) Stallter

Christopher Brown (1736-1820), b. & d. Stonington Connecticut; Capt/CT
>>Edith (Heighton) Clark

William Cloyd (1751-1837), b. Ireland, d. TN; Pvt/PA
>>Frances (Foster) Rafferty

Henry Cowan/COWING per DAR (1734-1830), b. Europe, d. Rockingham VA; Pvt/VA
>>Helen (Hainline) Andrews
>>Iola Pearl (Cowan) Hainline

Nehemiah Davis (1755-1793), b. & d. MA; Pvt/MA
>>Ida Dudley (Craw) Miller

Phillip Dotterer (1729-1790), b. & d. PA, Capt & Patriotic service/NJ
>>Mary (Brower) Wolfe

Elias Dugan/DUNGAN (c1742-1804), b. & d. PA; Pvt/PA
>>Vida (Constable) Dye

Aaron Evans A037398 (1739-1786), b. & d. NC; Patriotic service/NC
>>Frieda (Alexander) Fricke 

John “Jacob” Fast (1752-1827), b. MD, d. Fairfield Co OH; bur. Fast Cemetery, Fairfield Co OH; Patriotic service/VA
>>Alice (Fast) Hartzell
>>Mary Alice Thomas

Asa Hall (c1760-1814), b. CT, d. Portage Co OH; Pvt/CT
>>Mildred C (Hamilton) Fischer
>>Ada (Hall) Hamilton 

David Hamilton (1742-1817), b. & d. Hampden Co MA; Lieut/MA
>>Doris Barber
>>Jean (Murlin) Rawers

John Kumler “Jacob” (1742-1815), b. Switzerland, d. Berks Co PA; Patriotic service/PA; Per DAR, “lineage problem on at least one proven application.”
>>Ida (Zeller) Stubbs

William McCutcheon (1750-1842), b. & d. VA; Pvt/VA
>>Winifred (Johnson) Reiser 

Isaac Manning Jr (1742-1827) b. & d. NJ; 2nd Lieut/NJ
>>Catharine (Blackburn) Sharp

 William Murlin/MORELAND per DAR (1735-1810) b. Cornwall England d. Northumberland Co PA; Patriotic service, soldier/PA; his son went name of Murlin [1]
>>Ruth (Hoel) Brandts
>>Thelma (Parrott) Hale
>>Janice (Perrott) Heisser
>>Zua (Murlin) Maurer
>>Mildred (Hoel) Pulskamp

William Neeley (1735-1819), b. & d. PA; Pvt, Patriotic service/PA
>>Helen (Kennedy) Riley

William Roebuck (1755-1809), b. Northumberland Co PA, d. Fayette Co OH; per DAR: “Future applicants must prove correct service.”
>>Ollene (Green) Straley
>>Belva (Dine) Stubbs
>>Charlotte (Putman) Wright

Jesse Rose (1760-1852), b. VA, d. Mahoning Co OH; Soldier/VA
>>Helen K Freeman 

George Seeger (1744-1824), b. Lancaster Co PA, d. Union Co OH; Pvt/PA
>>Virginia (Honnold) Wiley

George Ward (1757-1791), b. & d. VA; Pvt/VA
>>Golda Shiverdecker
>>Glee Swigart

Unfortunately, none of these Revolutionary War patriots are buried in Mercer County, but it is still interesting to take a look at patriotic service group that was once in Mercer County.

[1] William Moreland’s son went by name of John Murlin (1770-1822), b. NY, d. Hardin Co KY; John’s wife Sarah Dodderer (1776-1842) died in Mercer County, Ohio.

More Revolutionary War Soldiers Who Lived in Mercer County

Continuing with Revolutionary War Soldiers who may be buried in Mercer County, Ohio, I came across a couple sources that give information about Revolutionary War pensioners who lived in Mercer County.

The Pension Roll of 1835 lists everyone who had a pension from their Revolutionary War service. Several Revolutionary War pension acts came into play over several years and there were restrictions concerning who could receive pensions.

The first pension law in 1776 granted half-pay for life to soldiers disabled in the service and unable to earn a living. The first pension law based on service was the Pension Act of March 1818, which offered a lifetime pension to soldiers who had served at least nine months in the Continental Army and who were in reduced circumstances. They amended the 1818 Act in May 1820, to more precisely define what reduced circumstances were. As a result, the 1820 Act required that new applicants submit certified financial schedules to prove their assets were less than $100. All soldiers who were granted pensions based on the 1818 Pension Act were struck from the pension rolls and were required to reapply in 1820. Only about two-thirds of the original applicants reapplied under the new act by December of 1821.

Pension Roll of 1835, Mercer County, Ohio.

The U.S. Pension Roll of 1835 is divided by states, then by county. Below are the soldiers who received a pension while living in Mercer County, according to that record: 

Ira L. Foster, Private, 19th Regular U.S. Infantry; commencement: 7 Jun 1815, placed on rolls 30 Jan 1816 & 24 Apr 1816; allowance: $30.00, received $26.41 and allowance: $48.00, received $857.31. [per 1816 Act]

James Shoonover, Private, New York Militia; pension enrollment date: 25 Aug 1820; residence: Mercer County, Ohio; allowance: $96.00; received $1298.83. [per 1816 & 1820 Acts]

William Berry, Pvt, Virginia Militia; commencement: 4 Mar 1831, age 81; placed on pension roll 25 Jun 1833; annual allowance: $24.66; received $73.98.

John Latimer, Pvt, New Jersey Militia; commencement: 4 Mar 1831, age 83; placed on pension roll 6 May 1833; allowance: $59.16; received $177.48.

Robert M’Lumsey [McCumsey?], Pvt, Pennsylvania Militia; commencement: 4 Mar 1831; placed on roll 6 May 1833; allowance: $40.00; received $120.00.

Amos Spencer, Pvt, Virginia Continental; commencement: 17 Jun 1823. age 75; placed on roll 10 Dec 1833; allotted: $96.00; received $1028.76. [1]

There are a few more names listed here than I mentioned last week.

Pension Roll of 1835, Mercer County, Ohio.

The 1835 list of pensioners includes the names all who received a pension, even though some of those listed may have died before 1835.

You can calculate some additional information from these records, such as estimated birth year, estimated the death date, and how many years they received a pension.

Using that reasoning, William Berry was born about 1750 and received a pension for about 3 years. John Latimer was born about 1748 and received a pension for about 3 years. Robert M’Lumsey [McCumsey?] received a pension for about 3 years. Amos Spencer was born about 1748 and received a pension a little over a year. It appears that James Shoonover received a pension for about 13 years, maybe more.

The following from another source, the 1838 Pension records:

Doc. No.1: [a pension certification]
…War Department, Invalid Pension, Mercer County, per Acts of 1816 and 1820, James Shoonover, No. 803, Private, Capt. Harding’s Company, NY Militia, commanded by Col. Dobbin…$8/per month, to commence 25 Aug 1820…resides in Mercer County, Ohio, and has resided there for five years… previously resided in Pike County, Ohio. Signed by James Shoonover, BF Schroeder, Oliver Ellis, and Caleb Major, JP. Dated 29 March 1838. [Note that James Shoonover’s name is crossed out on this document.]

James Shoonover, 1838 Pensions & Misc Records, Mercer Co, Ohio.

Doc. No.3: [authorizing Samuel P Worthington to receive James Shoonover’s pension]
…I, James Shoonover, of Mercer County, Ohio, an Invalid Pensioner of the US, do hereby appoint Samuel P Worthington my attorney…to receive from the Agent of the US for paying Pensions in Cincinnati…from 4 Mar 1837 to 4 Mar 1838. Signed James Shoonover, witnessed 29 Mar 1838, by BF Schroeder, Oliver Ellis, and appearing before Caleb Major, JP. [2]

James Shoonover, 1838 Pensions & Misc Records, Mercer Co, Ohio.

The 1840 Census: A Census of Pensioners for Revolutionary or Military Services gives pensioners’ names, ages, place of residence, and the name of the head of family with whom the pensioner resided on 1 June 1840. From Mercer County:

Dublin Twp: John Sutton, age 84, resided with Isaac H. Sutton
Wayne Twp: John Latimer, age 84, resided with William Latimer [Wayne Twp, Auglaize County, then part of Mercer County]
Washington Twp: James Shoonover, age 44, resided with James Shoonover [his age of 44 does not seem correct] [3]

That 1840 source gives another name, John Sutton. John Sutton was enumerated in Dublin Township, in 1840.

1840 Census, Rev. War Pensioners, Mercer Co. Ohio.

These pensioners had to prove they had reduced circumstances. If they did not have the means, they may not have left property to probate or sell. I found none of these men in Mercer County’s old Probate Records, except for the will of one John Sutton (1790-1852), who was born after the American Revolution.

Another thing to consider is that Mercer County was created on 1 April 1820 and organized on 2 January 1824. It was created from Non-County Area 6 attached to Darke County and Non-County Area 7 attached to Shelby County. The county was named after Revolutionary War officer Hugh Mercer. When Mercer County was fully organized in 1824, it detached from Darke County and was larger than it is today. Two counties were eventually formed from the original Mercer County: Van Wert County, in 1837, and part of Auglaize County, in 1848. In addition, Allen County was part of Mercer County from 1828-1831.

Revolutionary War Pensioners may have lived and received their pensions in what was Mercer County at the time but may have died in a county that was later formed from Mercer County. [4]

In conclusion, here is a summary of where these American Revolution soldiers resided in Mercer County, per the US Census and the 1827 and 1843 Mercer County Quadrennial Enumerations:

Ira L. Foster, Private, 19th Regular U.S. Infantry; 1840: Jefferson Twp; 1843: Quadrennial Enumeration, Jefferson Twp; 1850: not found.

James Shoonover, Private, New York Militia; c1833 moved to Mercer County from Pike County; 1843 Quad Enum, Washington; 1850: not found; reportedly buried in Macedon Cemetery, Mercer County. [One James “Icoonover” was enumerated in 1840, Washington Twp, but he was too young to have served in the American Revolution. Perhaps he was the son of patriot James Shoonover?]

William Berry, Pvt, Virginia Militia; born c1750; 1827 Quad Enum, St. Marys; 1830: St. Marys town; 1840 & 1850: not found.

John Latimer, Pvt, New Jersey Militia; born c1748 (maybe later); 1843 Quad Enum; 1830-1850: not found

Robert M’Lumsey/McCumsey, Pvt, Pennsylvania Militia; 1830: St. Marys Twp, listed as Sr; 1840-1850: not found.

Amos Spencer, Pvt, Virginia Continental; born c1748; not found in Mercer County in the censuses or Quadrennial Enumerations; reportedly buried in Macedon Cemetery, Mercer County.

John Sutton, born c1756; 1827 Quad Enum, Dublin Twp; 1830 & 1840: Dublin Twp; 1850: a John Sutton, age 59, in Dublin Twp, possibly a son?

One additional source indicates that Robert Kirkwood, Henry Leasor, William McMahon, and William McMeachen are buried in Mercer County. [5]

I found no additional information about Henry Leasor, Revolutionary War soldier, who is also reportedly buried in Murlin Cemetery, Mercer County.

This is still a work in progress, but we know the names of some Revolutionary War soldiers who lived in Mercer County late in their lives. The ones who had pensions.

These are the ones who once lived in Mercer County, but are they buried in Mercer County?

And there may have been even more living in the county because not every soldier took a pension.

[1] U.S., the Pension Roll of 1835, State 6, Ohio; Ancestry.com. [this source is also on FamilySearch.org]

[2] 1838 Pensions, Mercer, Ohio, Miscellaneous Records 1838-1911, James Shoonover; and
1838 Pensions, Mercer, Ohio, Miscellaneous Records 1838-1911, James Shoonover; FamilySearch.org.

[3] 1840 Census: A Census of Pensioners for Revolutionary or Military Services, Mississippi, Louisiana, Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Missouri, Arkansas, p.177; United States Census Bureau.

[4] Ohio Atlas of Historical County Boundaries, Ohio Individual County Chronologies, Newberry Library, 2007.

[5] The Official Roster of the Daughters of the American Revolution Buried in the Sate of Ohio, FJ Heer Printing, Columbus, Ohio, 1929.

Revolutionary War Soldiers Buried in Mercer County

America’s 250th anniversary is next year and the official America 250 celebration has begun. With that comes an interest in Revolutionary War history and the patriots who fought for our county’s independence.

I have been asked if there are any Revolutionary War soldiers buried here in Mercer County, Ohio. That is a good question and I am not really sure of the correct answer.

According to the Graves Registration Cards at the Mercer County courthouse and the Fort Recovery Monument, there are at least five Revolutionary War soldiers buried in Mercer County, but there may be more. Tombstones do not exist for those five, although two of them have been memorialized on the Fort Recovery Monument.

Henry Leasor (1733-1833), Revolutionary War, buried in Murlin Cemetery, Union Township. Henry Leasor and his father William, an immigrant from Scotland who settled near Richmond, Virginia, both served in the Revolutionary War and received land grants for their service. After the Revolution, Henry moved to Hardin County, Kentucky. In 1832 his daughter Elizabeth married Abram Murlin and moved to Union Township, Mercer County. While visiting his daughter Elizabeth in Mercer County, Henry was killed by a falling tree and was buried on the Murlin farm. [1]  

Henry Leasor, Mercer County, Ohio, Graves Registration Card

James Shoonover (no dates), Revolutionary War, New York Militia, Capt. Hardings Company, reportedly buried at Macedon Cemetery, Washington Township. On the back of his Graves Registration Card: Cemetery record from Mr. Doner, whose father was the caretaker 60 years ago.

James Shoonover, Mercer County, Ohio, Graves Registration Card

Amos Spencer (no dates), Revolutionary War, Army, Virginia Continentals, reportedly buried at Macedon Cemetery, Washington Township. 

Amos Spencer, Mercer County, Ohio, Graves Registration Card

Two Revolutionary War soldiers, Capt. Robert H. Kirkwood Jr and Staff Officer William McMahon, are officially recorded as buried at Fort Recovery Monument Park. Kirkwood was killed during St. Clair’s Defeat, aka the Battle of Wabash, on 4 November 1791. McMahon was killed during Anthony Wayne’s Victory on 30 June-1 July 1794. The Fort Recovery Monument was erected by Congress in 1912, in memory of those two battles and is located on Elm Street in Fort Recovery.

Fort Recovery Monument (2025 photo by Karen)

Capt. Robert H. Kirkwood Jr (1756-1791), born in New Castle County, Delaware, served in Delaware during the American Revolution. He died at Fort Recovery on 4 November 1791, during St. Clair’s Defeat by the Indians. …By now a widower, in 1791 he [Kirkwood] was commissioned a Captain in the 2nd US Infantry which was tasked with building a line of forts in the Northwest Territory. Having come out of 32 Revolutionary War battles without a significant wound, Robert Kirkwood’s luck finally ran out. One of his companions described his death, “There, resting beneath a tree, lay old Kirkwood, scalped…” [2] Kirkwood has been proved by the DAR and the SAR.

Officers’ names inscribed on circles on Fort Recovery Monument (2025 photo by Karen)

Staff Officer William McMahon (1749-1794), born 9 January 1749 in Wilmington, New Castle County, Delaware, served in Virginia during the American Revolution. He died in battle on 30 June 1794, during Anthony Wayne’s Victory at Fort Recovery. McMahon was a doctor/surgeon of the 3rd & 4th Regiments. McMahon has been proved by the DAR and the SAR.

Those appear to be the five Revolutionary War soldiers who are buried in Mercer County.

However, there may be more Revolutionary War soldiers buried in Fort Recovery. During those battles in 1791 and 1794, in addition to the officers listed as killed, regular soldiers also fought, were killed, and were buried there. Some of them may have also served in the Revolutionary War.

Roll of the Dead, Fort Recovery Monument (2025 photo by Karen)

ROLL OF DEAD
St. Clair’s Defeat
Major General Richard Butler
Colonel Oldham
Majors Ferguson, Hart, Clark, Lemon, Griggs & Montgomery
Captains Bradford, Phelon, Kirkwood, Price, VanSwearingen, Tipton, Purdy, Smith, Piatt, Gaither, Crebbs & Newman
Lieutenants Spear, Warren, Boyd, McMath, Burgess, Kelso, Read, Little, Hopper & Likens
Ensigns Cobb, Balch, Chase, Turner, Wilson, Brooks, Beatty, Purdy & Bines
Quartermasters Reynolds & Ward
Adjutant Anderson
Surgeons Grasson, Chase & Beatty
Officers Ford, Morgan, Butts, McCrea, Thompson, McNickle, Crawford, Morehead, Doyle & Cummings
13 other Officers
630 American Soldiers

Wayne’s Victory
Major McMahon
Captain Hartshorn
Lieutenant Craig
19 Officers
120 American Soldiers

The surnames of the officers are listed, but without their given names and a lot of additional research, it is not known who among them may have served in the Revolutionary War. Plus, 32 other Officers and 750 American Soldiers who died are not named, some of whom may have served in the American Revolution.

Someone has gone to a lot of work on Find a Grave.com, listing 556 memorials for soldiers buried at Fort Recovery Monument Park. These memorials include Officers and enlisted men, most from the 1791 battle, along with some veterans of more recent conflicts. The Find a Grave soldiers’ memorials from the 1791 battle come from soldier lists and lists of those killed. [3]

That would be quite a research project to determine who among that list of soldiers killed also fought in the American Revolution.  

Maybe someone has already done that.

Yes, a simple question with a complicated answer.

Another bronze plaque on the Fort Recovery Monument:

Plaque on Fort Recovery Monument (2025 photo by Karen)

This monument was erected by the congress to commemorate the valor and perpetuate the memory of the heroic soldiers who were here slain in those two memorable conflicts of the North West Territory, the defeat of Arthur St. Clair and the Victory of Anthony Wayne.

It marks the sacred spot where lie buried the fallen heroes who so bravely met and fought the savage foe. Who as advance guards entered the wilderness of the west to blaze the way for freedom and civilization. Who sacrificed home and life to the great duty of securing for a future inheritance vast dominions and great institutions…

[1] The Official Roster of the Soldiers of the American Revolution Buried in the State of Ohio, 1929, p.223. Information from Henry’s grandson, at age 80, and grandmother, as told to great-granddaughter, Mrs. Lillian Thomas, 226 W. Livingston St, Celina.

[2] Capt. Robert Henry Kirkwood, Find a Grave Memorial no. 71818366, Fort Recovery Memorial Park; Find a Grave.com.

[3] Winthrop Sargent’s list of Killed and Wounded at St. Clair’s Defeat; and The Soldiers of America’s First Army 1791 by Richard M. Lytle.

Tombstone Tuesday-Fredrick Wilhelm Grabner

Fredrick W Grabner, St. Paul Lutheran, Liberty Twp, Mercer County, Ohio. (2025 photo by Karen)

This is the tombstone of Fredrick Wilhelm Grabner, located in row 4 of St. Paul Lutheran Cemetery, Liberty Township, Mercer County, Ohio. The marker is broken at the base and partially sunken into the ground. Most of the inscription is unreadable, but The Mercer County Chapter OGS read and recorded the inscription in 1990. Their 1990 reading:

Fredrick W.
Son of
John & M
Grabner
Died
Sep 22, 1846
Aged
3Y, 6M, 21D

The major problem with this tombstone inscription is that the tombstone carver transposed the last two numbers of the year Fredrick W. Grabner died. Fredrick W. died in 1864, not 1846.

Several records support this.

The records of St. Paul Liberty show that Fredrick Wilhelm Grabner died 28 September 1864, at the age of 3 years, 6 months, and 28 days. That church record and the one below refers to him as William.   

St. Paul’s records also indicate that Fredrick Wilhelm was born in Liberty Township on 1 March 1861, the son of John and Magdalene “Lena” (Maurer) Grabner.

Fredrick’s parents were both born in Germany and his father immigrated to America in 1847. Fredrick’s parents married at St. Paul Liberty, Mercer County, on 17 January 1852, married by Rev. J.G. Gackenheimer. [1]

Yes, there are some minor date discrepancies between the tombstone inscription and the church records, I feel the church records are more accurate than the tombstone.  

Fredrick Wilhelm Grabner’s tombstone is next to grave marker of his brother John Anton Grabner (1866-1868), which is also broken and lying on the ground.

Brothers John A & Fredrick W Grabner, St. Paul Liberty Cemetery, Mercer County, Ohio. (2025 photo by Karen)

The John Grabner (Sr) family lived in Section 11 of Liberty Township, about 1½ miles east of St. Paul Lutheran Church. The family attended church at St. Paul Lutheran Church and the following information about the family is recorded in their church records.

From St. Paul Lutheran, Liberty Township’s Familienbuch:
Johann Michael Graebner, son of Johann Michael and Maria Elisabetha Graebner, was born on 17 August 1822 in Schellert, County Court an der Eisch, District Mittelfranken, Kingdom of Bavaria, where he was also baptized and confirmed. He immigrated to America in 1847 and lived in Butler County, Ohio, for a few years. He married Magdalena Maurer in Mercer County in 1852. Magdalena was the daughter of Nickolaus and Margaretha Maurer, and was born on 28 February 1832 in Guedingen, District Saarbruecken, Prussia. She was baptized and confirmed in Bischnissheim. John and Magdalena (Maurer) Grabner lived in Mercer County since their marriage, where their following children were born and baptized:
George, born 9 January 1853
Paulina, born 18 December 1854
Luisa, born 8 December 1856
Maria, born 9 November 1858
[Fredrick] William, born 1 March 1861, died 28 September 1864
John Anton, born 30 April 1866 [2] 

That family record stopped at 1866, but the couple had at least two additional children: Carolina Margaretha Grabner, born 29 November 1863, baptized 31 January 1864, and confirmed in 1877. Her confirmation is recorded at both St. Paul Liberty and Zion Lutheran, Chatt. Another child, Henry Jacob Grabner, was born 11 December 1870, confirmed at St. Paul in 1885, and died 19 April 1950. He never married and is also buried at St. Paul Liberty Cemetery.   

This surname is spelled several ways in the various records: Graebner, Grabner, and Grapner. The oldest spelling of the name in the church records is Graebner and Grapner is today’s spelling.

Find a Grave.com has a better photo of Fredrick’s tombstone that I was able to get. 

[1] Ohio, U.S., County Marriage Records, 1774-1993, Mercer County Marriage Book C, p.161, John Grabner & Magdalena Moner [sic], 17 Jan 1852; Ancestry.com. And marriage records of St. Paul Liberty Lutheran Church, Mercer County, Ohio.

[2] Familienbuch, St. Paul Liberty Lutheran Church, Liberty Township, Mercer County, Ohio, p.33, previously translated from original records.